Summary

Ann Rule's "The Want-Ad Killer" meticulously chronicles the chilling case of Harvey Carignan, a man whose sinister facade concealed a terrifying predator. Set against the backdrop of Seattle and Minneapolis in the 1970s, the book begins with the disappearance of Kathy Miller, a bright 15-year-old who answered a want ad for a job. As detectives Billy Baughman and Duane Homan delve into Kathy's vanishing, they uncover a disturbing pattern, a chilling connection to Harvey Carignan, a name that soon becomes synonymous with dread.

Rule expertly lays bare the investigation, detailing the mounting frustration of law enforcement as they grapple with Carignan's cunning manipulation and the legal constraints that hinder their pursuit. The narrative shifts between the perspectives of the investigators, the victims, and Carignan himself, painting a comprehensive portrait of a man driven by rage and a twisted sense of justice. The detailed descriptions of crime scenes, forensic analysis, and psychological profiling create a gripping sense of suspense as the detectives race against time to prevent further atrocities.

As the scene moves to Minneapolis, Detective Archie Sonenstahl picks up the trail, linking Carignan to a series of brutal attacks and murders. The book delves into Carignan's past, exposing a history of violence, abuse, and a chilling belief in his divine mission to punish women he deems "harlots." The courtroom drama unfolds, revealing Carignan's calculated attempts to feign insanity and the battle between psychiatrists to determine his mental state. Rule masterfully captures the tension and uncertainty as the jury weighs the evidence, grappling with the question of whether Carignan is a madman or a cold-blooded killer.

"The Want-Ad Killer" is more than a true crime story; it is an exploration of the complexities of justice, the vulnerabilities of victims, and the chilling darkness that can lurk beneath a seemingly ordinary exterior. Rule's meticulous research and captivating storytelling create a haunting and unforgettable account of a predator who exploited the system and left a trail of devastation in his wake. It serves as a stark reminder of the importance of vigilance and the enduring impact of violent crime on individuals, families, and communities.